Exciting day today; I went on a special tour of the East Wing of the White House courtesy of my sister-in-law Corinne. We toured the ground floor, which is beneath the Presidential residence, has the Green Room, and has the Red Room where the First Lady would receive female visitors. We nearly didn't get in. Secret Service people said we weren't on the list (which I think is an American equivalent of *clickety clack* Computer says no. *cough*), but Corinne got us in an hour later than we should have. They are apparently tightening up security after that infamous couple recently gate-crashed a White House event. How was it? Actually, a little underwhelming.
Don't get me wrong, it was certainly a privilege, a once in a life time opportunity, but from an aesthetic perspective I felt it was a touch hollow. The building itself lacks the kind of majesty one would find in the Winter Palace in St. Petersburg (1), but perhaps that is evidence of a little Puritan modesty. It was an ordinary kind of marble tiled floor and wood panelling walls. I saw a very nice antique foot stool thing, half hidden behind a curtain, but maybe it was French and therefore out of fashion. There was a cabinet which showed pieces of various Presidential dining crockery sets, including Lincoln's (1). They tended to be surprisingly ornate and often quite beautiful. The most prominent artworks are the painted portraits, vintage but conventional. The one exception is the portrait of Kennedy, which is in a more modern style showing him with his arms crossed and head down, troubled; perhaps he is thinking how to avoid a nuclear war over missiles in Cuba, or maybe his back is playing up. There was one painting I really liked, a Romantic/Transcendental landscape with a man, back to viewer, standing next to a huge tree. He is overwhelmed by the landscape, the person is dwarfed and made insignificant.
It is a contrast to the many large portraits which capture the stern authority of the President (Kennedy excepted). In fact, it was put up high, out of the way; I guess no one could work out what do with it. The portraits show the great men who walked the halls of the White House, and I think therein is the aesthetic disconnect. The White House is impressive because of those who live and work in it; it is, arguably, the centre of world. The value of the place is not in the structure itself, but what occurs inside it, what is introduced into it. I guess it is like the Institutional theory of art in reverse, or a thematic reverse of the Romantic painting I mentioned. I was looking for aesthetic value in the material, when the thrill of the experience is actually found in what the material represents. Few can walk the corridors of power, and I am grateful for the wondeful opportunity and the unforgetable experience.
(1). For an interior image of the Winter Palace. http://www.flickr.com/photos/baby7/251813113/
(2). Images of White House China. http://www.americanheritage1.com/white_house_china.htm
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

A different architectural intent, i think, to that of Albert Speer for AH - i often think it fortunate for the aesthetic perspective as well as every other (and of course more compelling) reason that Germany didn't end up winning WWII. What would the world have done with all those hideous, grandiose, humanity-dwarfing monuments?
ReplyDeleteTrue, but there is something a little Speerian about the Capitol building (photos will follow when I visit it). I saw a doco on WW2 by Niall Ferguson today (there is almost a Nazi channel on TV here, worst than SBS). Hitler thought America was a decadent society and would soon collapse, whereas Germany had 230 Opera halls and was therefore (a) superior culture.
ReplyDelete