Saturday, December 12, 2009

My mother, sister (Cristal) and brother (Nevil) arrived from Australia last night. So the whole family is here, but I'll have to fight to get a little cuddle time with Elizabeth.

I didn't do to much today, just read a little trashy sci-fi and had a long nap on the couch. Seeing as how I spent today reading, it is an opportune time to discuss book stores here. For me, bookstores are an almost religious experience; some hold the faith with the ideals of Literature, and others are heretically corrupted by popularism (ok, this is a slight exaggeration). I can't walk past a bookstore without going in, because I like looking at books, but also to evaluate their representation of Literature. To start small, I was delighted to see a small second hand bookstore here in Alexandria which focused on Literature. I mean that the around half of their bookshelves were devoted to fiction, and specifically Literature fiction as opposed popular fiction. This distinction may seem a little arbitrary and erroneous, and so it is, but a general distinction can be made. There is a bookstore franchise here, Books-A-Million. Most of the fiction books in this store are not what one would call big L Literature. The shelves marked Fiction/Literature were a curious mix of canonical and popular authors. Clive Cussler and Tom Clancy write Literature? Would one normally put Cussler and Clancy next to Joseph Conrad? Strangely, Jane Austen is located in another section, on the opposite side of the store in a section labelled Fiction.

They had a small section labelled Black Literature which immediately attracted my attention, but I was disappointed. I expected to see an array of the Black canon: Toni Morrison, Frederick Douglass, Alice Walker, James Weldon Jones, Nella Larsen, du Bois, but no, there was only a single copy of Ralph's Ellison's Invisible Man. The vast majority of the books seemed to be Mills and Boon type romance books but with Black characters, most noticeable with the cover picture. I wonder if it was, on the whole, an authentic Black voice manipulating the conventional genre, or merely using the standard genre template with superficial Black Characters.

Another large section was Christian fiction. Again, they more mostly in the romance genre, but without the sex. A lot of them were period dramas, with colonial maidens having to decide between love, sex and honouring God. No doubt it all worked out in the end. Instead of scantily dressed vixens on the cover they had innocent young women wearing Puritan clothing, but a slight hint of sexuality. The science fiction/fantasy section was a little limited too.

Naturally there was a big section on Christianity, all the different denominations and various devotional purposes. While they did have a small philosophy shelf, with a few token classics, there were more on Eastern religion/philosophy. The politics section was a little disappointing, half of which were individual polemics, such as "right wing critic X thinks that the left wing is destroying America", and "left wing critic Y thinks that the right is destroying America". There was little critical analyses. And the military section was a little limited. Ok, so Books-A-Million was not really that good.

There is also a Catholic bookshop in Alexandria run by nuns, actual nuns in habits. It was reasonably large, with many tracts and books, which I assume would address and doubts or problems, and lots of icons and rosaries and such. I also came across a speciality children's and young adult's bookstore. I was surprised not to find antique or old type book stores here considering the the historic nature of the community. On the whole, bookstores in Alexandria were a little disappointing.

In Washington, however, was a Barnes and Noble. Wow. A big selection of Literature. All the authors were here, and a reasonable selection of their works, and with the occasional Norton Critical Edition scattered throughout which warms my heart. I did spot checks, and everyone I looked for was there, even a single Patrick White (Vivisector). And books in the States are cheap. If you think the orange Penguin books are cheap, B&N had a stand of new books under $10 starting from $4.00. Conrad's 'Heart of Darkness' was there for $4.95, and I thought I could buy a shitload of them, take them back to Australia and sell them at uni for $15 (Heart of Darkness, which is one of my favourites, is studied a lot at ANU). There is even a poetry section! From Chaucer through to contemporary poets like Ginsberg and such. They had a good selection of Charles Bukowski, and I bought his 'Last Night of the Earth Poems', which has his great poem 'Dinosauria, We' (1). A very extensive selection of graphic novels and manga, and a good range of science fiction and fantasy, although I did notice a few gaps. The political section was a little limited though; there were about twice as many books on cooking as there were on politics, and again little actual critical books. Strangely, the best range of critical books, and by this I mean an informed analysis and intellectually curious investigations of issues, were actually at the Spy Museum gift shop. I guess the Museum is a little leftward leaning as they had a good, but not especially large, selection of political texts at the academic level dealing with sensitive issues such as terrorism, insurgency and political Islam, and other political issues. I find it strange that the main political books that sell are the celebrity polemics. There are lots of Congressmen, generals, critics (often right wing, like Hannity or O'Reilly) and think tank consultants who write manifesto type texts. One interesting thing, it is ok to sit or lie on the floor and read in bookstores. And naturally, Barnes & Noble has a large coffee shop.

To get back to what I originally was talking about, I've been reading trashy science fiction; it is fun and easy to read. Science fiction is a genre which generally is considered to be popular fiction rather than Literary, but such distinctions overlook the capacity of sci-fi to function as good Literature does, to examine what it is to be human. Sci-fi has the unique capacity to do so through examining situations that are beyond realistic or actual situations, to use the fantastic as a metaphor or literary device. A theme of the book I'm reading deals with the possibility of knowledge or language to change the observer. This is quite interesting, to understand something new leads to the reader becoming new, different. It is not an original theme is sci-fi; Samuel Delany covered it in his award winning book 'Babel 17', and so did Jack Vance in the excellent 'Languages of Pao'. These two are based on the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which argues that the cultural values inherent in language determines how the individual perceives the world. Consider that certain words have different connotations separate from their strict literal definition. What if 'soldier' had the same connotations as 'saint'? While the theory has been heavily criticised, it does raise interesting questions, and science fiction is a good way of examining the possibilities of the theory. Consider this in connection to the earlier point I made about Liberty and the other signs which commonly and thoroughly function in American society.

(1). http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hRc6mHS9PjE

5 comments:

  1. Views on bookstores - Amen, brother.

    Big L literature...can you describe for me the defining characteristics of this kind of writing? Academic writing has an obvious purpose, to transfer information, thought, ponderings on specific subjects from one to many. Much fiction serves an equally obvious purpose - to entertain, distract, provide an escape or an outlet. This is generally know as popular literature (at least in my parlance).

    What is Big L lit, how do you recognise it, what purpose does it serve - and has the chicklit of centuries gone by become the Big L literature of today (so to speak)?

    ReplyDelete
  2. For me, the defining characteristic of big L Literature is that it questions the reader. Popular fiction is self-contained, one can read it and enjoy then put it away with everything nicely resolved. Literature on the other hand should raise questions for the reader to resovlve, it should unsettle, still nag when read and put away. It should raise fundemental questions of the nature of human things. While popular fiction may be comfortable and familiar, Literature should show the reader something different. But the distinction is not clear cut, not black and white. I forgot to mention, with regard to Barnes & Noble, James Ellroy. He is located in the Mystery section, which includes true crime and who dunnits. While he had a few of his new release 'Blood's a Rover' in hardcover, there was only one of his books on the regular shelves, a solitary 'Destination Morgue'. I find this curious considering his popularity and reputation, perhaps they may have sold out before Christmas, but I don't think so.

    ReplyDelete
  3. So whether something is literature or Literature is highly contextual - and will differ greatly from reader to reader? What I mean is, books that challenge the minds of many in one culture/time/place because the concepts are so unfamiliar to that populace might be considered blasé in another...

    This is like modern art, isn't it? The value of an individual piece is completely subjective, and those who love it, spend their lives studying it, teaching it, discussing it, really understand what each other is talking about, and can collectively place a very high value/merit on something the general public is unable to see within the piece.

    So if literature is about good story-telling, about leaving the reader satisfied with their experience of that particular storyworld; and Literature is about provoking thought, about inciting a deeper examination of some topic, or of oneself, leaving the reader dissatisfied to some extent...how popular can Literature be?

    Must the author always set out deliberately to write big L, or does someone occasionally write something that 'strikes that chord' without meaning to? How many people who set out to write big L succeed and how many fail to reach an audience, their audience, any audience? And is there a middle ground - literature that is a rollicking good story, which nonetheless deliberately contains a deeper layer that somehow highlights some aspect of humanity's experience in a way that provokes thought - big L in disguise, as it were? Possibly a very effective strategy for delivering a message to the masses - wrap it up in popular fiction.

    Lots of questions there...hope you don't mind :-)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your comments on sci-fi notwithstanding, of course.

    And BTW, there were possible overtones of the devaluing of cookbooks in this blog...food is more important than politics - politics can lead to the absence of food, but you need a regularly full stomach in order to conduct political campaigns...

    Any such overtones may lead to reduced culinary services in the future...just think about what your stomach will have to say to you if this happens! Heh heh

    ReplyDelete
  5. Emerson had three rules regarding books and reading:
    1. Never read any book that is not a year old. 2. Never read any but famed books.
    3. Never read any but what you like
    His essay on Books is worth reading in itself
    http://www.rwe.org/complete-works/vii---society-and-solitude/chapter-viii--books

    I think the purpose of literature has changed over time (perhaps more akin to modern art) and its reception is subjective. Also, keep in mind that the novel is a relatively new development. What the novel does, with realism and such, is different to the epic poetry that went before. You mentioned storytelling, Walter Benjamin lamented that the novel was displaing storytelling http://slought.org/files/downloads/events/SF_1331-Benjamin.pdf

    But for the author, the difference between a Literary author and a popular author is perhaps irrelevent, it depends on what one wants to write, what one wants to give the reader. I read and enjoy Westerns and some trashy sci-fi, and I respect authors, such as Louis L'Amour, for there ability to tell a good story. L'Amour may not write High Literature, but his name better recognised and more respected than say Thomas Pynchon.

    Cookbooks would be a seperate kind of category, cooking is (or should be an art), and a such relates the experiences of art.

    ReplyDelete