Friday, December 18, 2009

Remember. This is the message of the US Holocaust Museum.
In the Hall of Remembrance there is a passage from Deuteronomy:
"Only be careful, and watch yourselves closely so that you do not forget the things your eyes have seen or let them slip from your heart as long as you live. Teach them to your children and to their children after them." 4:9
I was not permitted to take photos in the exhibitions, but I will share some stories of the things I saw. Above, this is from President Clinton's dedication.




This the main foyer. The major aesthetic theme here is gun metal gray, cold and hard steel. The girders are exposed, they are the main theme. They cut through the red brick walls on either side, and the windows are covered by metal slats or bars. Despite the high roof, there is a sense of confinement here, oppression, the girders become prison bars



This is the seating area in the main foyer, and again the cold and hard impersonality of steel is prominent. The steps and raised platform are made of anti-slip steel sheets, and the seat at bottom right is made of steel sheets 1cm thick. It is a deliberate and common motif, inside the exhibitions there a steel gratings and objects are held behind steel mesh or bars.






The motif is made most evident by this sculpture; it is a solid sheet of steel, 3 metres square and about 20cm thick.






There is currently a Nazi Propaganda exhibition, which I think is very important in highlighting the effects of Othering, and its subsequent function in enabling oppression. The final image is of Iran's Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, and his statement of advocating the elimination of the Israeli state.

In the permanent exhibition one can see, and walk through, an actual rail car used to transport Jews and other to concentration camps. It is made of a crude and thick hard red wood. It measures about three meters by eight meters, and the curved roof is about 2 meters high. It is dark, very dark inside. There are four windows in each corner, measuring about 20cm by 60cm. While all have wooden flaps to seal them, two can be opened for a small rectangle of light and air, and the other two have slats which limit light and air. Up to 100 people would be transported at a time in these, and for many days, without food or water, and without opening the doors and windows.

There is also part of a barracks from a concentration camp. It is made of basic pine planks. The walls are tightly built so that there are no cracks between the planks, but the roof is not made so well, there are a few millimeters gap between each plank which would let in the snow and rain. With it are real Zyclon B containers, the poison used to gas prisoners by asphyxiation.

The displays of personal items taken from prisoners are effective; piles of hair brushes, scissors and razors. In one room the floor is covered by, perhaps, a thousand shoes, mouldering leather shoes and slippers from rich and poor alike. Edward R Murrow, the American journalist, said "One pair of shoes, two pairs, and dozen pairs, how does one describe thousands of shoes." Many prisoners were shave before execution, and their hair was sold to civilian corporations for use in mattresses, cheap felt etc. When the Russians took Auschwitz they found 15,000 tonnes of human hair.

They have a punch card proto-computer processing machine on display, the technology necessary to manage such a huge logistic task as Jewish identification and implementing the Final Solution. It bears the stamp of IBM, the machines were produced before and during the war by an IBM subsidiary in Germany.

Over four rooms, vertically, about three meters wide, five meters long, and about 20 meters high, is a display of photographs from a small Jewish town in Lithuania. From a period from around 1890 to 1941, they are conventional photographs one would find in home, family portraits and the like. The town's Jewish inhabitants, over 4000 people, were executed over 2 days, and 900 of history destroyed with the exception of the photographs. They can now only be remembered by the photographs.

While the main focus of the Museum is to remember the Jewish Holocaust, it directs the emotional response to that towards averting future acts of genocide. One small exhibition covers the Bosnian, Rwandan and Sudanese genocides. More than merely remembering, it prompts the visitor to act against racism and hatred. The gift shop, which naturally does not contain tacky crap, deals with justice in a broader sense, with books dealing with contemporary issues as well as the Nazi oppression of Jews and others. For example, one can find Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird, Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse 5 and Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451.

Security there is very tight, armed guards outside, who also check cars entering the carpark for bombs, metal detectors and x-ray machines. The is a memorial poster there for Stephen Johns, a Black security officer who was shot and killed earlier this year when confronting James von Brunn, a rifle toting 88 yo neo-Nazi who intended to shoot a lot of Jews, Blacks, and whoever else he could.

In one exhibit quote, a concentration camp was described as bestial, but I find this problematic. One could argue that the Final Solution was something very human, the worst of humanity no doubt, but a human act nonetheless. Science fiction writers, as with Star Trek, posit the human subject as an ideal. Philip K. Dick, in an attempt to come to terms with German atrocities, explored the theme in his fiction through robots, distinguishing between humane humans and robotic humans. He argued in an essay (I forget exactly which one), that humans who acted as did those German troops and civilians who participated in the Holocaust, acted mechanically without moral reflection, like an insect. A problem I find in demonising Nazis is that it removes them from humanity; one can look at them with some objectivity and without self-reflection. There motives and thoughts, while extreme and terrible, and not wholly distinct from a large percentage of the human population. While Nazis were capable of such incomprehensible brutality, did they not love their own children? I think we should say "We did this" rather than "They did that". To what extent have we, the wider global community, sanctioned the genocide in Dafur through inaction? So if the Holocaust was a human act, in the sense that is was committed and sanctioned by many real humans, then what is the human?

1 comment:

  1. You know my thoughts on this. The human is but a bewildered chimpanzee - thus the title of my first novel "Tales of a Modern City: Lament of the Bewildered Chimpanzee". We are as we are - there was no guiding hand, no divine spirit molding us over the generations from Australopithecine to Homo sapiens sapiens. Our environment shaped us, along with random genetic chance, until we began to shape ourselves - after all, [in the Western Christian paradigm] we are not created in God's image - he was created in the image of Man (and I use the term Man advisedly - He is not female).

    To breathe, to eat, to drink is chimpanzee. To create and use tools, to huddle together for warmth is chimpanzee. To be sexual with each other, to have strong emotional ties with each other, to lie, to cheat, to steal, to murder one's own kind is chimpanzee. To learn and pass on knowledge is chimpanzee. To care for the sick, the dying, the weak, those of another species is chimpanzee. To victimise others because they belong to another group, to kill others in ways most horrific, to kill your community's children and cannibalise them is chimpanzee. All the pathologies, all the altruism, all the joy and wonder and fun and laughter and horror of chimpanzee is also human.

    In our bewilderment at finding ourselves existing as we do, alive, endlessly craving one thing or another, adopting a wide variety of personal codes from the extreme altruist to the extremely self-centred, with no apparent innate meaning to life - except perhaps for that we choose to give it ourselves - we seem to strive endlessly for self-definition - on both a societal and individual basis. We will accept the definitions of us imposed by others if they remove our existential discomfort - even at great cost to the quality of our own life. Certainty over horrible, horrible freedom - and with it, the responsibilities of total freedom.

    We don't seem to try to cherry-pick the behaviours of chimpanzees that we like and say 'that is chimpanzee', while the behaviours we don't like are 'inchimpanzee'. I think you are right - the behaviours we exhibit - both desirable and deplorable - are all human.
    Wonderfully and regrettably human. To say the ones we don't like are 'inhuman' is but to reject those aspects of our collective existence that we wish to disown, or not to have to deal with. Humans are, after all, masters of denial (which is just another form of lying to both ourselves and others - again, something we are very, very good at.)

    ReplyDelete